Skip to Content
Call to Setup a Consultation 215-515-9901

Is It Better to Divorce or Stay Unhappily Married?


Marriage, while ideally envisioned as a lasting partnership, can be susceptible to deterioration over time. Factors like unmet emotional needs, diverging priorities, and unresolved conflicts can gradually erode marital harmony.

Communication, once a cornerstone, may dwindle, replaced by criticism, defensiveness, or a detached silence. Intimacy, the fuel of connection, may wane, leaving a void where closeness and affection once resided.

If this happens, you may be left with a daunting question: should you remain in an unhappy marriage or choose the path of divorce? This choice is complex and deeply personal. It's not about choosing between good and bad, right and wrong. It's about choosing what's best for you—your mental health, your happiness, your future. In this post, we aim to provide you with the necessary insights and steps you can take if you are considering divorce.

What to Do If You’re Unhappy in Your Marriage

We cannot tell you what the right decision to make is. However, we can offer insight into what steps you can take to empower you to make a decision. Below, we offer a few things you can do if you’re unhappy in your marriage and contemplating divorce.

Take Time to Understand Your Feelings

Emotions are like compasses; they guide us towards what feels right and steer us away from what feels wrong. When you find yourself at the crossroads of staying in an unhappy marriage or opting for divorce, it's essential to take time to reflect on your emotions. This deep introspection can lead to self-awareness, clarity, and ultimately, the strength to make a decision that best serves your emotional and mental wellbeing.

Whatever emotions you are feeling—anger, sorrow, confusion, numbness, or grief—these emotions give you more opportunities to understand how to approach the crossroads you’re at. The more in tune you are with how you feel now, the better you will understand how you feel about each future decision, and the better you can assess which of your options align with your happiness and peace of mind rather than external pressures or expectations.

Talk with Your Spouse

Once you know where you are mentally and emotionally, you should have an open and honest conversation with your spouse. Share what you are feeling in general about your marriage and about what your next steps should be.

In approaching this conversation, remember to use “I” statements, like “I think…,” “I feel…,” and “I have experienced…,” as this strategy can help prevent your spouse from feeling attacked. “I” statements can also help avoid conflicts about you trying to tell your spouse how they feel.

You should also remember that this discussion is just meant to help your spouse understand how you feel and give you the opportunity to see if your spouse is feeling similarly. You both can also discuss a way forward together, but there shouldn’t be pressure to make a decision immediately. This conversation can simply be a starting point.

When you initiate the conversation, ask to have the discussion in a neutral, calm location and time. It is best to have the conversation when you both are in a place (literally and emotionally) where you both feel safe and comfortable.

Consider Professional Counseling

A marriage counselor or therapist can greatly benefit you if you are unhappy in your marriage. They can act as a neutral facilitator and guide during conversations with your spouse, which can be especially helpful if you and your spouse struggle to communicate.

Professional counselors can also facilitate conversations that help you and your spouse address issues that may be at the root of your unhappiness. During sessions, your counselor can also help you set a goal and develop a session schedule that works toward you answering the question of whether you should divorce or stay married.

Whatever decision you make, they can also help you navigate the fallout and journey you’ll take based on that choice. For instance, if you decide to pursue divorce, you can focus your sessions on how to tell your children about the divorce, what you can do to prepare yourself emotionally for divorce, and how you can navigate the process.

Get a Better Idea of Your Legal Options

If you decide divorce or separation is the best option, you should consult with an experienced divorce attorney. Even if you are still on the fence, you can discuss your options with an attorney to be informed.

During a consultation, an attorney can discuss what your legal rights are in a divorce and can offer you personalized counsel concerning questions you may have about alimony, child custody and support, property division, and other divorce matters.

Make an Informed Decision in Your Own Time

Remember, there's no 'one size fits all' solution here. It is important to avoid judging yourself or others who are grappling with similar situations. Instead, focus on understanding the nuances involved in this decision and exploring ways to mitigate the potential negative outcomes, whichever path you choose.

Consequences of Staying Married If You’re Unhappy

Staying in an unhappy marriage can have a profound impact on the individuals involved, their family, and the relationship itself. Here are some of the short-term and long-term effects to consider:

Short-term effects include:

  • Stress. Unhappiness in a marriage can often lead to chronic stress, which can negatively affect both physical and mental health.
  • Decreased self-esteem. Being in an unhappy relationship can erode one's self-esteem, making them doubt their worth and abilities.
  • Social isolation. Unhappy partners may isolate themselves from friends and family, leading to a lack of social support.

Long-term effects include:

  • Depression. Continuous stress can contribute to depression and other mental health disorders.
  • Decrease in physical health. Chronic stress can also lead to various health problems, such as heart disease, high blood pressure, and a weakened immune system.
  • Financial instability. Unhappy marriages often involve financial disagreements, which can lead to instability and insecurity.
  • Negative impact on children. Living in a tense, conflict-ridden environment can negatively affect children’s emotional wellbeing and development.
  • Quality of life. The overall quality of life may severely degrade due to the constant unhappiness and tension.

Consequences of Divorce

A good divorce can be better than a bad marriage. However, divorce, even when it’s the right decision, is not without its consequences. Getting divorced can impact you emotionally and legally.

One of the profound effects of divorce is on mental and physical health. The emotional toll of ending a marriage can manifest in various ways, such as stress, anxiety, depression, or even post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). These conditions, if left untreated, can negatively impact one's overall well-being, affecting sleep patterns, appetite, and productivity.

Also, chronic stress is linked to numerous physical health problems, including heart disease, high blood pressure, and a weakened immune system. It's crucial to seek professional help to manage these potential health issues effectively.

Financially, divorce can lead to significant changes. The division of assets, alimony, child support, legal fees, and the transition from a dual-income household to a single-income one can strain your financial stability. It's essential to consult with a financial advisor as well as an experienced divorce attorney to understand the full financial implications and plan accordingly.

Finally, if children are involved, the impact on them must be considered. Divorce can disrupt their sense of security and routine, leading to emotional distress, academic struggles, and behavioral issues. However, it's important to remember that children can also adapt and thrive, especially when parents maintain a cooperative relationship and prioritize their children's needs.

Divorce Counsel in NJ & PA

At William Kirby Law, Family Law Attorneys, our attorneys offer quality representation to New Jersey and Pennsylvania families and couples. Should you be considering divorce, we are here and prepared to provide you with personalized counsel and answers to your questions and concerns. When you retain our services, you can trust that we can help you develop a personalized case strategy.

Contact our team via phone at (215) 515-9901 or online using our contact form.